ENGG 1111: Critical Reading and Writing
University of Denver, Fall 2001
sections 12 & 17

Welcome! Critical Reading and Writing is the first course in the First-Year English sequence.  We will study readings rich in academic content across the disciplines but appropriate to the non-specialist. We will discuss and write our responses to these works in order to challenge and test our own assumptions and to develop a confident writing voice. We link reading and writing as critical inquiry and reflective learning, and we provide instruction in the basic conventions of academic writing, along with mastering details that contribute to the development of an interesting, unified, organized, coherent essay of substance. For every assignment you will need to be aware of voice, audience, and purpose. As preparation for the academic writing you will do in all your courses at DU, your essays for this class will be responses to the essays you read in our text and will, in some way, respond to the course theme: The Individual and the Making of Meaning. All students must pass a standardized English departmental exit exam in order to advance to Argument and Research. On completion of this course, students are expected to have developed the following skills:

  • critical reading, interpretation, and summarizing strategies; 
  • a basic understanding of the rhetorical situations of writing for a purpose, including academic writing, with an audience in mind, and to express a strong personal voice;
  • the ability to write an interesting essay that is unified, organized, coherent, and substantive, demonstrating competent use of grammar, punctuation, and syntax;
  • the basic skills of word-processing and the ability to post your best essay on your electronic portfolio.
QUICK LINKS: Click here for information on course policies.  Click here for extra-credit and writing-assistance opportunities. Click here for information on the e-portfolio.

Required Texts: Critical Strategies for Academic Thinking and Writing (Rose and Kiniry, 3rd ed.), Opening Doors: Guide to First-Year English (Whitt, Walpert, and Black, 13th ed), and The Merriam-Webster Dictionary.

SCHEDULE
    TOPIC

 

ASSIGNMENT

RP = response paper
page numbers refer to Critical Strategies

Week One M 9/10 introductions/

course overview

 
  W 9/12 in-class writing sample bring Opening Doors: Guide to First-Year English and a blue book
  F 9/14 Defining: Negotiating Meanings read: introduction to Chapter 1 (1-20)

write RP 1: Write a page describing your previous writing experiences. What types of writing have you done? What are your best and worst experiences?

Week Two M 9/17 rhetorical situation, the writing process read: Mairs, "On Being a Cripple" (29-36)

write RP 2: (see response paper guidelines to get started)

  W 9/19 paraphrase and summary read: Chase, "How to Save Our National Parks" (50-54) 

write RP 3

  F 9/21 invention  read: Rose, "From Possible Lives: The Promise of Public Education in America" (62-65)

write RP 4: Type one sentence from this reading, then write a paraphrase of it. Then write a paragraph summary of the whole reading. Finally, respond to the reading with about a paragraph of your thoughts.

Week Three M 9/24 revision read: Haugeland, "From Artificial Intelligence: The Very Idea" (69-75)
  W 9/26 workshop essay 1drafts due (see workshop guidelines)
  F 9/28 effective titles essay 1 due in folder (with all drafts, see essay guidelines)
Week Four M 10/1 Summarizing: Synthesis and Judgment read: introduction to Chapter 2 (78-94); Katz, "Poverty" (154-160); and Scheller, "On the Meaning of Plumbing and Poverty" (161-164)

write RP 5

  W 10/3 more about revision read: Sommers, "Revision Strategies of Student Writers and Experienced Adult Writers" (135-143)

write RP 6

  F 10/5 introductions and conclusions meet in Sturm 411
bring your laptop and ethernet cable
Week Five M 10/8 Serializing: Establishing Sequence read: introduction to Chapter 3 (170-186); Miller, "Reconstructing a Crime" (192-193); and Thomas, "The Sounds of Seal Society" (198-201)
  W 10/10 workshop essay 2 drafts due
  F 10/12   essay 2 due in folder (with graded version of essay 1)

read: Bennett and Feldman, "From Reconstructing Reality in the Courtroom: Justice and Judgment in American Culture" (276-281)

Week Six M 10/15 Classifying: Creating and Evaluating Categories read: introduction to Chapter 4 (285-308)
  W 10/17 focus read: Brink and Saunders, "The Phases of Culture Shock" (332-333) and Cole, "Five Myths about Immigration" (308-311)

write RP 7

  F 10/19 midterm exam bring Critical Strategies and a blue book
Week Seven M 10/22 Comparing: Assessing Similarities and Differences read: introduction to Chapter 5 (420-444); "An Aranda Creation Story" (450-451); and Abell, "The Big Bang Theory" (451-452)
  W 10/24 comparison and contrast read: Franklin, "From Autobiography" (452-454) and Malcolm X with Alex Haley, "From The Autobiography of Malcolm X" (455-461)

write RP 8

  F 10/26 workshop essay 3 drafts due

 

Week Eight M 10/29
essay 3 due in folder (with graded versions of essays 1 and 2)
  W 10/31 Analyzing: Perspectives for Interpretation read: introduction to Chapter 6 (556-580)
  F 11/2   read: Fox Keller, "The Language of Science" (598-599) and Goodfield, "Biologist Anna Brito: The Making of a Scientist" (599-605)

write RP 9

Week Nine M 11/5 class cancelled  This week: attend one "In My Own Voice" in Boettcher Auditorium (7-9 pm), Monday-Thursday 
  W 11/7 class cancelled  
  F 11/9 workshop essay 4 drafts due 
Week Ten M 11/12 meet at library for introduction to research presentation ticket from "In My Own Voice" due (to receive credit for last week’s classes)
write RP 10: a review of the "In My Own Voice" presentations in light of what you’ve learned this quarter about writing effective essays.
  W 11/14   essay 4 due in folder (with graded versions of essays 1-3)
  F 11/16   review for exit exam
NOTE: e-portfolio essay  must be posted by 5 pm today!
Final Exam Period SAT.

11/17

exit exam 11:00 class (section 12) exam held 10:30 am - 12:15 pm

1:00 class (section 17) exam held 1 pm - 2:45 pm

COURSE POLICIES

Please consult Opening Doors: Guide to First-Year English for English department policies on plagiarism, attendance, conferences, the Honor Code, and the Exit Exam. 

Attendance: You are a vital member of our community, and regular attendance is essential. You are allowed three absences with no penalty; additional absences and chronic late arrivals will affect your final grade adversely (-25 points each instance after first three). If you have an emergency medical absence, please obtain documentation. Any student eligible for accommodation of special learning needs should speak with me during the first week of class. The best way to contact me outside of class is to send an email; I will respond as soon as I receive your message. 

Assignments: Please bring your Critical Strategies textbook to class every day. If you have a question about any assignment, ask me—I'm happy to help. Assignments are due in class, at the beginning of class, on the due date to receive full credit. Assignments will be accepted one class period late (this will result in a reduction of five points) but not after that unless you have received permission for an extension.  Please do not email or fax assignments.

Academic Responsibilities: All work must be your own, generated this quarter. Turning in work that you have completed for another class is academic dishonesty. Plagiarism involves using all or part of a source (words or ideas) without correctly citing the source (this would include representing another person's work as your own or using a source without correct documentation). You are responsible for asking me if you are not sure how to document something. Academically dishonest or plagiarized work will receive an "F" and may be grounds for further disciplinary action (see Guide 39-40 for more information).  See also the DU Honor Code.

Response Papers: You will write a number of short response papers, 1 page long and typed (double-spaced). On each response paper, please include your name, the date, the response paper number, and the topic discussed. A response paper should reflect your critical reading of a text: after reading the text at least twice, take a position on something or explore one specific aspect of the text in detail. The following list may help you focus on a direction for discussion:

  • explore the structure of the text: is it unusual or surprising? what is the result?
  • discuss a specific point of comparison to another text we’ve read and draw a conclusion
  • discuss the implications of the text’s main "issue"
In all cases, you should make specific references to the textual evidence for your idea (quote where necessary). Be specific in naming the ways that the readings provide evidence for your ideas. I'm looking for thoughtful responses that demonstrate your active consideration of the course material—not a summary of the reading itself. Please bring your response paper to class on the day that the particular reading to which you are responding appears on the schedule. 

Workshop Guidelines: We will be working as a community of writers in this course, and you will take part in several workshops. Workshops provide the important opportunity for you to give and to receive feedback within a group of writers familiar with your writing goals. In order to receive full credit for workshops, you must bring the requested amount of copies of your draft in progress and give written feedback to all of your group members: you will receive 30 points if you have 2 copies of your draft and you give feedback to others, 20 points if you have 1 copy of your draft and you give feedback to others, and 10 points if you only give feedback. If you are not here for workshops, you cannot make up the points. 

Critical Essay Guidelines: Workshop drafts and final versions of your essay should be word processed in a 12-point standard font (e.g., Times New Roman, Garamond, Arial, etc.); see Guide for manuscript format guidelines, standards for grades, and a revision checklist (41-46). Aim for the length requirement; half a page over or under is acceptable. Please proofread carefully. I am looking for a clear original thesis supported by specific and relevant evidence discussed in a well-developed and well-organized essay. You should integrate some paraphrases and/or short quotations where appropriate—documented, of course, with parenthetical citations and a works cited list in MLA format (see Guide 191-195 and 215-216). When you turn in a final version of an essay, please include all of the drafts leading up to your final version. Then, each time you turn in a new essay, also include the graded version of earlier essays. (So when you turn in essay three, for example, you will turn in all drafts of essay three and the final version of essay three, plus the graded versions of essays one and two.)

Editing Sheets: We will go over this together in class, but please see Guide 46-48 for information on the editing sheet. You will need to do an editing sheet for each essay that you write. Your graded essay will have numbers in the margins that correspond to the Bellwether Handbook in the Guide. Use the chart on the back of the Guide to determine the area of correction necessary. When you make the correction, you may write just the word before and after the change (instead of writing the whole sentence each time). If you have more than 20 errors, just do the first 20. Editing sheets are due one week after I return your graded essay.

Exit Exam and Electronic Portfolio: You will receive more information on the exit exam, which includes the posting of your best Critical Reading and Writing essay on your electronic portfolio, later in the quarter. Please note, however, that you will need to successfully pass the exit exam in order to move on to Argument and Research. 

Final Grade Framework: You determine your grade from this day forward, so do ask me if you have any questions about the assignments or anything else. To earn the most possible points, come to class prepared and on time, do your own work to the best of your ability, turn in the work on the due date, and participate in class—your grade will reflect your efforts! Your final grade will be based on the following framework (adjusted for absences/lates if necessary).
 
Essays 400
Exit Exam 200
Midterm Exam 100
Response Papers 100
Workshops 120
Editing Sheets   80

1000 points total
930-1000 = A
830-879 = B
730-779 = C 630-679 = D 
900-929 = A-
800-829 = B-
700-729 = C-
600-629 = D-
880-890 =B+
780-799 =C+
680-699 =D+
0-600 = F

GOOD THINGS TO KNOW

Writing Assistance: The Write Place, staffed by English instructors, is a valuable resource for you. The Write Place operates on a walk-in basis, and the instructors can help you develop or revise your writing assignment (note: the Write Place is not a proofreading service). If you receive an "R" (revision required) on an essay, we will discuss your paper; then you will need to go to the Write Place with your revised version before re-submitting the essay (have the tutor sign and date your paper when you go in). The center is located in Penrose Library and in the residence halls (see Guide 35 for more information). 

Extra Credit Opportunities: A visit to the Write Place (other than for an "R") is worth five extra credit points (up to three times). To receive extra credit, (1) ask the the writing center tutor to sign his/her name legibly on the draft and to note the date and duration of your visit then (2) write "Write Place Copy" across the top of the draft. In addition, you may attend two literary readings during the quarter and write a one-page (typed) review for five points each—readings are offered at various places around town: at DU (see the English department web calendar for more information), at Tattered Cover, and at many other places (Westword provides a list each week).  You may also attend the grammar and punctuation workshops offered by the First-Year English program, for five points each, up to three times (see Guide for a schedule).

Some Important Dates: Last day to drop without signature: October 19, 2001; last day to drop with signature: November 2, 2001; final exam period, November 17-20, 2001.